For the buyer choosing between South Beach's two branded pre-construction residences, on facts, not adjectives.
This page explains. Whether the building suits you is a separate conversation. Contact the desk at Miami Dossier for the current position on any building we cover.
The Ritz-Carlton Residences, South Beach and Shore Club Private Collection are the two branded pre-construction residences competing for the same South Beach buyer. The Ritz-Carlton project is a 30-residence, 15-story oceanfront building at 1671 Collins Avenue from Sobe Sky Development with Flag Luxury Group, with delivery planned for 2027. Shore Club Private Collection is a 45 to 49 residence project from the Witkoff Group with Monroe Capital under the Auberge Resorts Collection flag, under construction with completion expected 2026-2027. Both are marketed by Douglas Elliman Development Marketing. The comparison below runs on verified facts: scale, sponsor, brand structure, delivery stage, and amenities. The desk holds the current file on both, so the live terms behind this comparison are one message away.
The Ritz-Carlton Residences, South Beach: 30 beach houses across 15 stories at 1671 Collins Avenue, layouts from one-bedroom to five-bedroom, including two duplex penthouses with private rooftop terraces, individual outdoor pools, and kitchens. Thirty residences is boutique scale. Fewer neighbors, fewer units sharing the amenities, and a smaller resale pool later.
Shore Club Private Collection: 45 to 49 residences in South Beach, a larger collection than the Ritz-Carlton's 30. More residences means more amenity cost-sharing across the association and a deeper eventual resale inventory.
The buyer question is not which scale is better. It is which scale fits the buyer. Boutique buildings trade exclusivity for a thinner resale market. Larger buildings trade some intimacy for liquidity. The desk frames it that way because that is what the numbers show.
The Ritz-Carlton Residences: developed by Sobe Sky Development, LLC with Flag Luxury Group. Sales launched in February 2025. Delivery is planned for 2027. The buyer verifies the sponsor's delivered record and the current construction milestone, as our developer guide details.
Shore Club Private Collection: developed by the Witkoff Group with Monroe Capital, under construction, with completion expected 2026-2027. Witkoff is an institutional-scale sponsor with a long public record of delivered large projects.
The stage difference matters. A project under construction and a project in pre-construction carry different delivery risk, and the market prices them differently. The buyer compares the current milestone of each against its target date, then weighs the terms each developer is offering today. Earlier stage can mean earlier pricing. Later stage can mean less waiting. Neither is free, and the desk's live file keeps both sides of that tradeoff current.
This is the comparison most buyers miss, and it may be the most important one.
At The Ritz-Carlton Residences, South Beach, the brand is licensed. The developer's own materials state that the residences are not owned, developed, or sold by The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company, and that Sobe Sky Development, LLC uses the marks under a license. The buyer verifies the license term, renewal mechanics, and what happens to services if the license changes.
At Shore Club Private Collection, the brand is the Auberge Resorts Collection flag, operated within a Witkoff-led development. The buyer verifies the management and brand terms in that project's documents with the same discipline.
Two different brand architectures, two different document reads. The buyer does not assume the brands work the same way. Counsel reads both sets of documents and reports the difference in plain terms.
The Ritz-Carlton Residences factsheet confirms: more than 50,000 square feet of amenity space, a private double-height lobby, 24-hour doorman and concierge, 24-hour valet, an amenity floor and terrace with a private lap pool on Level 7, four semi-private pool cabanas, a Technogym fitness center, and direct access to the Sagamore, the newly renovated all-suite addition to The Ritz-Carlton, South Beach, with restaurant and beach club programming by Michelin-starred chef José Andrés. Owners also receive benefits at more than 700 Marriott luxury hotels, based on availability.
Shore Club Private Collection's amenity program is built around the Auberge hospitality operation and the Shore Club's beachfront heritage. The buyer compares the two programs on the same terms: which services are included in the association budget, which are à la carte, and what the staffing model looks like after turnover.
The desk's rule: amenities are compared in the documents, not in the renderings. Included versus extra is a budget line, and the budget is in the offering materials.
Both projects sit in South Beach, and both trade on the district's identity. The Ritz-Carlton Residences is at 1671 Collins Avenue, adjacent to Lincoln Road, in South Beach proper. The buyer reads each project's exact block the way our neighborhood guide reads this one: the beach in front, the street in both directions, the neighbors, and the daily-life anchors.
A third reference point helps triangulate. The Perigon sits north in Mid-Beach at 5333 Collins Avenue, 73 residences from Mast Capital and Starwood Capital Group, topped out in March 2026 and reported more than 75 percent sold, with delivery expected in 2027. Three projects, three positions on the same coastline. The South Beach condo landscape rewards the buyer who compares all three on identical terms.
The buyer choosing between these two runs the same diligence on both, then decides on fit:
1. Sponsor record: verified delivered history and current construction milestone for each.
2. Brand terms: the license at the Ritz-Carlton project, the flag terms at Shore Club, each read by counsel.
3. Delivery timing: 2027 planned at the Ritz-Carlton project, 2026-2027 expected at Shore Club, each confirmed against today's milestone.
4. Scale fit: 30 residences versus 45 to 49, and what each means for privacy and resale liquidity.
5. Amenity economics: included versus à la carte, and the budget lines behind each.
6. Current terms: the desk's live file on pricing and availability for both, because the comparison that matters uses today's numbers.
No verdict is offered here because the verdict depends on the buyer's own weighting of these six. The desk's job is to make sure all six are verified before the buyer weights them.
Verify each sponsor's record and each project's current milestone. Verify each brand arrangement with counsel. Verify the amenity budgets line by line. Verify the current release terms for both projects in the desk's file. And verify insurance, flood, and entity structure with the same discipline our other guides describe. Two buildings, one standard of proof.
The desk keeps the current file on The Ritz-Carlton Residences, South Beach: plans, pricing, and availability as the developer releases them. If you want the private file, ask.
Contact the desk at Miami Dossier for the current plans, pricing and availability as the developer releases them, discussed one to one.
A private report on the Miami market, sent when there is something worth knowing. No noise, no listings, no pressure.
Received. A note from the desk is on its way. If it has not arrived within a few minutes, please check your spam folder and mark it as not spam, so we can reach you.
We hold no listings and we are not the developer. Contact the desk at Miami Dossier and we will tell you what applies to your situation, what does not, and where we would not proceed. Where a question is legal, tax or structuring, we introduce you to advisers who handle that properly rather than answering it ourselves.
Metrik Real Estate is a Miami real estate company built around one idea: the buyer gets their own team. Miami Dossier is its private buyer advisory for new construction.
A person replies within 24 hours, usually much sooner. On weekends, back on Monday morning.
